When we all lived in the forest
  • Home
  • Fantasy Reading
  • Science Fiction Reading
  • Publications
  • Amusements
  • Moth Books

#100: Dune by Frank Herbert

7/29/2015

0 Comments

 
I first read Dune when I was in eighth grade.  That first time I read it, when I got to the end, I flipped it back over and read it again.  Then I read it again and again, once a year through my teens and twenties, perhaps twice in my thirties, and once in my forties for this "100 Great Books of Science Fiction List," and I have just read it again, at the half century mark of fifty.

I was flabbergasted by Dune when I first read it, and I am again, just now, finishing it again.  Not because  it isn't flawed (there are flaws); not because of the intelligent use of sense of smell to evoke reality (the spice, the smell of the sietch, the salt of Caladan's ocean); not because of the artful weaving of scenes which completely are their own creatures but create something much more cohesive and greater in my mind; not because of the powerful and realistic portrayals of women; not because of dozens of other reasons why Dune is the best book science fiction has ever produced.

No, I am stunned because, for the very first time, in the first chapter I realized that Frank Herbert had to be a Buddhist. There was no way he could not be.  No way...

I looked it up: yes, Frank Herbert had converted from Catholicism to Zen Buddhism in the Sixties.  The Catholic and Muslim overtones of Dune had always been overt, exotic, and delicious in a way other books don't seem able to embrace: but as I read on, I also realized that this book could not have have existed without this particular philosophical spine and musculature.  At certain points in the book, the characters speak (and oft become) koans.  

I am wondering what else Dune will give to me (that I previously had no idea was there) in my future readings.

When I first reviewed this in 2008 for this list (and lost the review), I remember saying that a book need not be perfect to be great.  This time, I am going to lift a passage from Thomas Merton, that I read just today.  (As an aside, Frank Herbert took six years to write Dune.  This may be why the other books in the series do not speak to me the way Dune does. I'm thinking they must have been written much for quickly.) 

"In any case it is depressing that those who serve God and love Him sometimes write badly, when those who do not believe in Him take pains to write so well.  I am not talking about grammar and syntax, but about having something to say and saying it in sentences that are not half dead. ...Imperfection is the penalty of rushing into print.  And people who rush into print too often do so not because they really have anything to say, but because they think it is important for something by them to be in print.  The fact that your subject may be very important in itself does not necessarily mean that what you have written about it is important."

Thank you, Thomas Merton.  And thank you, Frank Herbert.  Thank you so much.

Picture
0 Comments

    This Page
    I read "100 Great Science Fiction Books" from 2005 to 2008, and they are described here, along with what I thought might could be good lessons for writers, gleaned from each.  Here is the INDEX for 100 GREAT SCIENCE FICTION BOOKS. 

    Me
    I write science fiction to make my head happy and fantasy to make my heart happy.  Neither of these are making money, but they make me happy, dammit it.

    Last Publication
    YARR! A SPACE PIRATE ANTHOLOGY!
    by Martinus Press

    Picture

    Archives

    January 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012

    Categories

    All
    1984
    334
    A Canticle For Leibowitz
    A Case Of Conscience
    A.E. Van Vogt
    After London: Wild England
    Alan Dean Foster
    Alas
    Aldous Huxley
    Alec Effinger
    Alfred Bester
    Alien
    Alternate History
    Alternate Universe
    A Mirror For Observers
    Anthem
    Apocalype
    Apocalypse
    Arkday & Boris Strugatsky
    Arthur C. Clarke
    A Wrinkle In Time
    Babel-17
    Babylon
    Barry M. Malzberg
    Beggars In Spain
    Berserker
    Blood Music
    Bob Shaw
    Bokonon
    Bokononism
    Bone Dance
    Brain Plague
    Brain Wave
    Brave New World
    Brian Aldiss
    Bring The Jubilee
    Buddhism
    Catholic
    Catholicism
    Cat's Cradle
    Chalicothere
    Charles L. Harness
    Childhood's End
    Chip Delaney
    Christopher Priest
    Clifford D. Simak
    Competent Man
    Cordwainer Smith
    C.S. Friedman
    Cyberpunk
    Damon Knight
    Daniel Keyes
    Dan Simmons
    Dennis O'Neil
    Douglas Adams
    Downward To The Earth
    Dream Snake
    Dune
    Dystopia
    Earth Abides
    Edgar Pangborn
    Emma Bull
    Ender's Game
    Engine Summer
    Euthanasia
    Eutopia
    Fahrenheit 451
    Fall Of Hyperion
    Far Future
    First And Last Men
    Flowers For Algernon
    For Love Of Mother Not
    Foundation
    Foundation Writer
    Fourth Mansions
    Frank Herbert
    Frederick Pohl
    Fred Saberhagen
    Fritz Leiber
    Galaxies
    Genetic Engineering
    Gene Wolfe
    George Alec Effinger
    George Clayton Johnson
    George Orwell
    George R. Stewart
    George Turner
    Grass
    Greg Bear
    Greg Egan
    Hal Clement
    Harlan Ellison
    Harry Harrison
    Heinlein
    Hell's Pavement
    Henry Kuttner
    H.G. Wells
    Hinduism
    Hot Head
    Hugo Gernsback
    Hyperion
    Ian Watson
    Ice 9
    In Conquest Born
    Isaac Asimov
    Islam
    James Blish
    James Tiptree Jr.
    Jane Yolen
    Jerry Pournelle
    J.G. Ballard
    Joanna Russ
    Joan Slonczewski
    Joe Haldeman
    John Brunner
    John Christopher
    John Crowley
    Johnn Crowley
    John Varley
    John Wyndam
    Jr.
    Jules Verne
    Julian May
    Juniper Time
    Karel Capek
    Kate Wilhem
    Keith Laumer
    Keith Roberts
    Kim Stanley Robinson
    Kurt Vonnegut
    L.A. Lafferty
    Larry Nivan
    Leonard Nimoy
    Linguistics
    Logan's Run
    Lord Of Light
    Lycidas
    Madeleine L'Engle
    Make Room! Make Room!
    Man Plus
    Marge Piecry
    Mars
    Mefisto In Onyx
    Michael Crichton
    Michael Moorcock
    Milton
    Mission Of Gravity
    M. John Harrison
    More Than Human
    Mutant
    Mythology
    Nancy Kress
    Nanotechnology
    Neal Stephenson
    Neuromancer
    Nicola Griffith
    No Blade Of Grass
    Non-Stop
    Nostrilia
    Oath Of Fealty
    Octavia Butler
    Olpah Stapledon
    Orbitsville
    Orson Scott Card
    Pat Frank
    Pavane
    Permutation City
    Philip Wylie
    Phillip Jose Farmer
    Phillip K. Dick
    Play
    Pliocene
    Poul Anderson
    Ralph 124C 41+
    Ray Bradbury
    Red Mars
    Richard Jefferies
    Riddley Walker
    Roadside Picnic
    Robert Heinlein
    Robert Silverberg
    Robots
    Roger Zelazny
    R.U.R.
    Russell Hoban
    Russian
    Samuel R. Delaney
    Science Fiction
    Shakespeare
    Shape Shifters
    Sheri S. Tepper
    Sietch
    Simon Ings
    Slow River
    Snow Crash
    Solaris
    Space Travel
    Spice
    Spider Robinson
    Spock
    Stanislas Lem
    Stephen Gaskell
    Stephen King
    Telepathy
    Thanatos
    The Andromeda Strain
    The Bite Of Monsters
    The Cards Of Grief
    The Centauri Device
    The Dancers At The End Of Time
    The Day Of The Triffids
    The Demolished Man
    The Disappearance
    The Doomsday Book
    The Door Into Summer
    The Drowned World
    The Drowning Towers
    The Ebedding
    The Female Man
    The Fiften Head Of Cerberus
    The Forever War
    The House In November
    The Inverted World
    The Left Hand Of Darkness
    The Man In The High Castle
    The Many-Coloured Lands
    Theodore Sturgeon
    The Opiuchi Hotline
    The Paradox Men
    The Prestige
    The Sheep Look Up
    The Unreasoning Mask
    The Voyage Of The Space Beagle
    The Wanderer
    The Year Of The Quiet Sun
    Thomas Merton
    Thomas Pinchon
    Time Pressure
    Time Travel
    Up The Walls Of The World
    Ursula LeGuin
    Utopia
    Vonda M. McIntyre
    Wales
    Walter M. Miller
    Ward Moore
    Way Station
    We
    What Entropy Means To Me
    When The Sleeper Wakes
    Wild Seed
    William F. Nolan
    William Gibson
    Wilson Tucker
    Woman On The Edge Of Time
    Yevgeny Zamyatin

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly